Directive lesson
Critically Analyse
This directive combines analysis with evaluation. Show how the parts relate, then test whether the explanation or proposition is convincing.
Use this flow
- Frame the proposition
- Analyse its components
- Present supporting evidence
- Test gaps, assumptions and alternatives
- Give a balanced judgement
Must do
- Move beyond description
- Question the strength of the causal link
- Use a nuanced conclusion
Avoid
- Treating it as ‘criticise’
- Listing pros and cons without analysing links
- Making an absolute claim from limited evidence
Real PYQ example
Critically analyse the proposition that there is a high correlation between India's cultural diversities and socio-economic marginalities.